Al-Baqillani’s Critique to Rafidite Syi’ites’ on the Seven Variant Reading of The Qur’an

Much Hasan Darojat, Mohd. Fauzi Hamat, Wan Adli Wan Ramli

Abstract

This article aims to delineate al-Baqillani’s response to the Rafidite Syi’ites’ claim on the invalidity of the variant readings of the Qur’an. As an Asy‘arite, al-Baqillani was able to disprove their claims dealing with the status of the variant readings of the Qur’an in the history of Islamic civilization. His arguments are also relevant to reject orientalists’s notion who are in line with those Syi’ites on the related topic. This issue has close relationship with the process of the compilation of the Qur’an and the validity of the Muṣḥaf of Utsman, since the Syi’ites rejected it and promoting their own version as claimed by their authoritative figures. The authors conclude that al-Baqillani’s defence on the matter provides number of evidence that the existing of the Qur’an is the one which was collected by Utsman ibn Affan. Al-Baqillani was also able to disprove the views that the variant readings of the Qur’an are merely ijtihâd and metaphorical statements. He clarified that the variant readings are valid and has been practiced by a number of companions and approved by the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. His views on this issue were also supported by other scholars like al-Qurtubi and al-Zarqani. In this research, the approach that has been applied is textual analysis, using descriptive and analytical methods to investigate and analyze primary sources related to the pertinent topic. It also adopts the historical method to scrutinize several events on the subject within the context of the history of Islam.

Keywords

Rafidite Syi’ites’; Asy‘arite; al-Baqillani; al-Qirâ’ah al-Sab’ah; Qur’an Compilation

Full Text:

PDF

Article Metrics

Abstract view : 304 times
PDF - 334 times

References

Abu Zahrah, Muhammad. N.Y. Al-Imâm al-Ṣadiq: Ḥayâtuh wa ‘Aṣruhu wa Arâuhu wa Fiqhuhu. Dâr al-Fikr al-Arabî.

Al-Amili, Ja‘far Murtadha. 2010. Ḥaqâiq ‘Âmmah ḥaula al-Qur’ân. N.P.: al-Markaz al-Islâmî li al-Dirâsât.

Azami, Muhammad Mustafa. 2002. Studies in Hadith Methodology and Literature. Kuala Lumpur: Islamic Book Trust.

_________. 2003. The History of the Quranic Text: From Revelation to Compilation. Leicester: UK Islamic Academy.

Basmeih, Sheikh Abdullah. 2007. Tafsir Ar-Rahman: Interpretation of the meaning of the Qur’an. Putrajaya: Department of Islamic Development Malaysia.

Al-Baqillani, Abu Bakr ibn Thayyib. 1998. Al-Taqrîb wa al-Irsyâd, Vol. 1 and 2, Ed. ‘Abd al-Hamid ibn Ali Abu Zunaid. Beirut: Muassasah al-Risâlah.

_________. 2001. Al-Instiṣâr li al-Qur’ân, Vol. 1 and 2. Beirut: Dâr Ibn Ḥazm.

_________. 2002. Manâqib al-Aimmah al-Arba‘ah, Ed. Samira Farhat. Beirût: Dâr al-Muntakhab al-‘Arabî.

Al-Bukhari, Abu ‘Abd Allah Muhammad ibn Ismail. 2010. Ṣaḥîḥ al-Bukhârî, Ed. Muhammad ‘Abd al-Baqi. Egypt: Dâr Ibn Ḥazm.

_________. 1986. Ṣaḥîḥ al-Bukhârî, Trans. Muhammad Muhsin Khan. Lahore: Kazi Publication.

Al-Ghifari, ‘Abd al-Rasul. 2012. Al-Qirâ’at wa al-Aḥrûf al-Sab‘ah. Qum: Markaz al-Muṣṭafâ al-‘Âlami li al-Tarjamah wa al-Nasyr.

Goldziher, Ignaz. 1985. Madhâhib al-Tafsîr al-Islâmî. Trans. ‘Abd al-Halim Najjar. Beirut: Dâr Iqrâ’.

Al-Hajjaj, Abu al-Husain Muslim. 1993. Ṣaḥîḥ Muslim. Beirut: Dâr al-Fikr.

Ibn Ishaq. Abu al-Faraj Muhammad ibn Ishaq ibn Muhammad. 1970. The Fihrist ibn Nadim, Ed. Bayard Dodge. New York: Columbia University Press.

Ibn Mujahid. 1972. Kitâb al-Sab‘ah fî al-Qirâ’ât, Ed. Syauqi Daif. Egypt: Dâr al-Ma‘ârif.

Ibn al-Sayyari, Abu ‘Abd Allah Ahmad Muhammad. 2009. Kitâb al-Qirâ’ât aw al-Tanzîl wa al-Taḥrîf, Ed. Etan Kohlberg. Leiden: E. J. Brill.

Ibn Surah, Abu ‘Isa Muhammad ibn ‘Isa. N.Y. Sunan al-Tirmîdhî, Ed. Kamal Yusuf al-Hut, Beirut: Dâr al-Fikr.

‘Iwadh, Ibrahim. N.Y. Ṣurat al-Nûrain allatî Yuz‘amu Farîq min al-Syî‘ah Annahâ min al-Qur’ân al-Karîm. Egypt: Dâr al-Zahra al-Syarq.

Jeffery, Arthur. 1937. Materials for The History of the Text of the Qur’an: The Old Codices. Leiden: E. J. Brill.

Al-Khu’i. 1981. Al-Bayân fî Tafsîr al-Qur’ân. N.P.: Anwâr al-Hudâ.

Al-Kulaini, 2005. Uṣûl al-Kâfî. Trans. Muhammad Sarwar, Chapter 40, No. 5. Beirut: Dâr al-Murtadha.

Lane, E. W. 1984. Arabic-English Lexicon. Cambridge: The Islamic Text Society.

Al-Mazandarani. N.Y. Syarḥ Uṣûl al-Kâfî, Vol. 5.Tehran: al-Maktabah al-Islâmiyyah.

Al-Mufîd, Muhammad ibn Muhammad al-Nu‘man ibn al-Mu‘allim. 1992. Al-Masâ’il al-Sarawiyyah, Ed. Saib ‘Abd al-Hamid, al-Mu‘tamar al-Alamî Li alfiah al-Syaikh al-Mufîd.

Al-Murtadha, Al-Syarif. 1937. Al-Majazât al-Nabawiyyah, Ed. Mahmud Musthafa. Egypt: Muṣṭafâ al-Bâb al-Ḥalabî wa Awlâduh.

Al-Murtadha, Al-Syarif. 1937. Al-Majazât al-Nabawiyyah, Ed. Mahmud Mustafa. Egypt: Mustafâ al-Bâb al-Halabî wa Awlâduh.

Noldeke, Theodor. 1892. Sketches From Eastern History, Trans. John Sutherland Black. London: Adam and Charles Black.

Al-Qasim, Abu Ubayd. N.Y. Faḍâil al-Qur’ân, Ed. Marwan al-‘Atiyya. Damascus: Dâr Ibn Katsîr.

Al-Qattan, Manna’. 2007. Mabâḥits fî ‘Ulûm al-Qur’ân. Egypt: Maktabah Wahba.

Al-Qurtubi, Abu Bakr. 2006. Al-Jâmi‘ li Aḥkâm al-Qur’ân, Ed. ‘Abd Allah ibn ‘Abd al-Muhsin al-Turki. Beirut: Muassasa al-Risalah.

Al-Razi, Muhammad Fakh al-Din. 1981. Tafsîr al-Râzî. Beirut: Dâr al-Fikr.

Al-Saduq, al-Syaikh. 1982. A Shi’ite Creed. Trans. Asaf. A. A. Fyzee. Tehran: World Organization for Islamic Services.

Saed, Abdullah. 2008. The Qur’ân: An Introduction. Oxford: Routledge.

Al-Saghir, Muhammad Husain Ali. 1999. Târîkh al-Qur’ân. Beirut: Dâr al-Muarrikh al-Arabî.

Al-Sijistani, Abu Bakr ‘Abd Allah Sulayman ibn al-Asy‘ath. 2002. Kitâb al-Maṣâḥif. Beirut: Dâr al-Basyâir al-Islâmiyyah.

Al-Suyuti, Jalal al-Din. N.Y. Al-Itqân fî Ulûm al-Qur’ân, Vol. 1. Beirut: Dâr al-Fikr.

Al-Tabarsi, Abu Ali al-Fadl ibn al-Hasan. 2005. Majma’ al-Bayân, Vol. 1, N.C.: Dâr al-‘Ulûm.

Al-Tabarsi, Abu Mansur Ahmad ibn Ali ibn Abi Thalib. 1960. Kitâb al-Iḥtijâj, Vol. 1. N.P: Intisyârât al-Syarîf al-Ridâ.

Tisdall, W. St. Clair. 1913. Muslim World, “Shi’ah Additions to the Qur’ân”, Vol. 3.

Ushama, Thamem. 2002. Issues in the Study of the Qur’ân. Kuala Lumpur: Ilmiah Publisher.

Al-Ya‘qubi, Ahmad ibn Abi Ya‘qub ibn Ja‘far ibn Wahb. 1883. Tarikh, Vol. 2. Leiden: Brill.

Al-Zarqani, Muhammad ‘Abd al-Azim. 1988. Manâhil al-Irfân fî ‘Ulûm al-Qur’ân. Beirut: Dâr al-Fikr.